pronouns: she/her is fine.

I am a conniving rat with plans of an international uprising against tyranny! I keep getting distracted by tasty food, gardening, gadgets, games, and books though.

Inside me are two wolves, I desperately need surgery.

  • 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 2nd, 2023

help-circle

  • Everyone is getting stupider except you right? Like you’re not one of the dumbed down lazy people are you? or your loved ones?

    People have said this shit since we have written records.The whole idea of fallen man is the foundation of the Abrahamic religions, probably others I don’t know of too.

    People are doing alright, actually go talk to some. Yeah yeah a lot aren’t crazy educated but even the most educated intellectual titans of our age are uneducated in the overwhelming majority of things.

    We do alright, there are many problems but they’re not because people are getting less intelligent. We are no smarter or stupider than the first humans, or at least we have no reason to believe otherwise. We have better access to information and we’re also facing some very large problems, but so did bronze age people.

    Read the epic of Gilgamesh, it’ll chill you out some.





  • Ok so we can take that stance. I would disagree that these are useful semantics because of the case I mentioned where I feel like adding a turret to a sandcaste is something meaningfully distinct from reducing a sandcastle to a pile of sand, walking 100 meters down the beach, and making a new one with the turret.

    Do you disagree that this is meaningfully distinct? If you do would you feel that it’s equivalent to do those two things? That you feel the same way about them?

    If you agree that it’s meaningfully distinct then why insist on framing it in the same concepts instead of using the concept of change?


  • You’re gonna have to start by pinning down terminology a bit.

    Change is a term often used which I think most people would feel is a usefully distinct word for example if I said: said:

    • “I created a sandcastle”
    • “I changed a sandcastle”
    • “I destroyed a sandcastle”

    I think those would mean something different to most people despite all reductively applying to the literal rearrangement of a pile of sand.

    So the obvious potential confusion here is in the case where I changed a sandcastle how would you decribe it? adding a turret could be taken as destroying the old one and creating a new one but it seems strange to me to argue for the throwing out of change as a concept since what I did seems meaningfully different from smashing a sandcastle, walking 100 meters, and building a new one.

    So could you elaborate on what you take creation and destruction to entail?